Okay, so, I’ve been grinding away at MLB The Show 23, and let me tell you, picking the right captain can make a huge difference. I wanted to share what I’ve learned about the best captains in the game, so here’s the lowdown from my experience.
Finding the Right Captain
First off, I started by experimenting with a bunch of different captains. I mean, there are so many options, and each one brings something different to the table. I spent hours just trying out different captains to see how they affected my team’s performance.

Testing Captain Boosts
Then, I really dug into the captain boosts. These can be a game-changer. Some captains give boosts to hitting, others to pitching, and some are more balanced. I carefully checked out what each captain offered and how those boosts aligned with my play style.
- Hitting Captains: I tried out captains that boost contact, power, and plate discipline. This was awesome for games where I wanted to focus on an offensive strategy.
- Pitching Captains: On the flip side, I tested captains that improve pitching stats like H/9, K/9, and control. These were great for when I needed to shut down the other team’s offense.
- Balanced Captains: There are also captains that provide smaller boosts across the board. I found these useful for a more well-rounded approach.
Building the Team
Once I had a good feel for the boosts, I started building my team around my chosen captain. This is where things got interesting. It’s not just about picking the best players; it’s about picking players that get the most out of the captain’s boosts. I spent a lot of time swapping players in and out, trying to find the perfect combination.
Playing Games
After setting up my team, I played a ton of games. I wanted to see how my team performed with different captains in various scenarios. It took a while, but I started to notice patterns. Certain captains just seemed to click with my style of play.
My Top Picks
After all that grinding, I found a few captains that really stood out. These are the ones that gave me the best results:
- For hitting, I really liked the captains that boosted power and contact. They helped me rack up those extra-base hits.
- For pitching, the captains that improved H/9 and K/9 were solid. They made it way harder for opponents to get hits and score runs.
- And for a balanced approach, there were a couple of captains that gave decent boosts to both hitting and pitching. They were perfect for when I wanted a bit of everything.
Final Thoughts
In the end, picking the best captain in MLB The Show 23 comes down to your personal play style and what you want to achieve with your team. It took a lot of trial and error, but I finally found the captains that work best for me. Hopefully, my experience can help you find your perfect captain too!